The Leading in a Crisis Podcast
What really happens when a crisis hits an organization—and how technology is influencing decisions and reputation impacts. Come hear what happened when experienced leaders were actually in the middle of a crisis—and capture the lessons before it happens to you. Email the show at Tom@leadinginacrisis.com.
Your host, Tom Mueller, is a veteran crisis manager and trainer with more than 30 years in the corporate communications and crisis fields. Tom currently works as an executive coach and crisis trainer with WPNT Communications, and as a contract public information officer and trainer through his personal company, Tom Mueller Communications LLC.
Our goal is to help you grow your knowledge and awareness so you can be better prepared to lead should a major crisis threaten your organization.
Music credit: Special thanks to Nick Longoria from Austin, Texas for creating the theme music for the podcast.
#crisis #crisismanagement #crisiscomms #crisiscommunications
#BusinessContinuity #LeadingThroughCrisis
#CrisisResponse #management #leadership
The Leading in a Crisis Podcast
NVIDIA’s leadership crisis and the board’s toughest test
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We unpack the governance fallout from the NVIDIA CEO crisis and why boards get blindsided when trust breaks down at the top. Our guest is Dr. Gregory Shea, a management expert and senior fellow at the Wharton Center for Leadership and Change Management.
Can the Nvidia board afford to keep an executive who has so egregiously violated company policy? There's even a petition - Stand with Jenson - that lobbies for due process for the embattled CEO. It has 180,000 signatures so far.
We argue that values only matter when they cost something, and that succession planning and truthful disclosure are the difference between leadership and damage control. Other key points:
• board chair and CEO trust as the most critical relationship
• sincerity versus honesty and why volunteering truth matters
• lack of a CEO succession plan and how it traps the board
• policy violations around workplace relationships and power lines
• why unequal discipline for executives destroys credibility
• investor confidence, stock drops and the long-term transition risk
• public rage over elite double standards and reputational spillover
• due process claims, CEO resignation realities and what it signals
• crisis communications under investigations and political pressure
• hiring the next CEO while recentering on core business
#Nvidia #boardofdirectors #crisiscomms #leadershiplessons #jensenhuang
You can reach Prof. Shea via LinkedIn.
We'd love to hear from you. Email the show at Tom@leadinginacrisis.com.
Welcome And Crisis Setup
Tom MuellerHi everyone and welcome back to the Leading in a Crisis Podcast. I'm Tom Mueller. Thanks for joining us again this week. On our show today, we're going to do a hot take on the corporate crisis that is enveloping the NVIDIA company and their embattled CEO, Jensen Huang. My guest today to talk through these issues is Dr. Gregory She, who is a management expert and a senior fellow at the Wharton Center for Leadership and Change Management. Now, Greg works closely with boards of directors and leadership teams that are facing leadership crises. So he's a great resource to sort of tap into some of the good governance issues that have been highlighted through this incident. Greg, welcome back to the show.
Prof Gregory SheaGlad to be back.
Tom MuellerAll right. Hey, it's an amazing story that we're seeing here. You know, part of it's the tale as old as time. Um, you know, love runs deep, especially for CEOs who are bored. You know, it just uh you look about you look across the you know the the last couple years and you see numerous examples of of this type of behavior. And uh it can be uh tough for board of directors to know exactly how to manage this. You've been watching this for a bit. How would you sort of rate what
The Board Chair CEO Relationship
Tom Muelleryou're seeing so far from the board?
Prof Gregory SheaWell, as with many things, Tom, and from your background, you're no stranger to how you present these kinds of crises to the world at large from the crises from inside of corporations. Um I'd actually one of the things that strikes me is um how how quickly we concentrate on whenever we decide the decided the bell rang, we kind of focus on that. Um and I'd I'd start by looking upstream here uh well and ask uh what was the relationship between the board and the CEO? I mean, how did he get this blindsided?
Tom MuellerRight?
Prof Gregory SheaNow that's not to not hold him accountable for his own actions. We're still trying to sort out what those are. When's a denial denial and when is it a retracted? I you know, that um somewhere somewhere in my children's lifetime, they'll sort that out. Uh, but for the moment, you'd say what was happening upstream in terms of the relationship between the board um and Jensen. Um and how could they be that that blindsided? And that's particularly about the relationship between whoever the board chair has been and is currently with with the CEO. Uh, this um when I worked with organizations, uh I Tom, this is this is basically this is the most important relationship in the organization. Uh the the the two of you have got to understand each other. Uh, and you've got to understand each other um in something that's I would say um more than professional. And I don't mean that you have to take holidays together, but you have to have some sense of each other as as people, your values, how you operate. Um when when the door gets closed and one of you asks a question of the other one, it should be uh without doubt that it's gonna be a clear answer to that question. And if there's something that's relevant that's going on, you don't have to wait for a question. You're gonna get the information, right? It's not,
Tom MuellerI
Prof Gregory Sheaoften draw the distinction between honesty and truth, you know, excuse me, between um sincerity and honesty. Um, you know, sincerity is I won't lie to you, honesty is I'll volunteer the truth to you. And these this should be an honest relationship, right? And they have to work on making that so. And I I'd say there's all kinds of indications that that was not the case. So before we get to the details of what happened, the question I say is what what what was the relationship between the board? How did they take up their role and what they thought it should be? And in particular, how did the how did the board chair uh take up his or her role uh vis-a-vis Wang?
Succession Planning As Crisis Insurance
Tom MuellerWell, the other issue that that comes to mind here is um, and there are numerous aspects to this, right? There's the crisis communications piece of it, there's the good governance, the board issues, which I've just been fascinated by the fact that there was no apparent succession plan for NVIDIA, uh, which you know many pundits have cited that as a as a big failing here. Um But you know, I liked what I heard initially from the board on this, which is they stood behind their man and were generally supportive of Jensen Huang, um, appointed uh outside directors to lead an investigation. And um, you know, and that was seemed to be an appropriate response for what we knew at the time. Of course, that changed a couple of days later when the New York Times revealed a second affair uh that Jensen was having or had had with a member of staff there at the company. Um so yeah, you know, it's it's it's tough to get ahead of the game when you're not sure what the game is, right? And but the board then, you know, I'm sure told him he was gonna have to go, and so he resigned. Um, but you know, if you're a board of directors and watching this stuff play out, is there any way to get ahead of the game right now?
Prof Gregory SheaWell, I mean, right now, right now, right now, two days ago, or right now four days ago. Um, you know, I think part of part of what the board did to complicate its life was what you just made reference to. There's no succession plan. Um, and certainly when I work with um the dozen or so CEO placements that I've been involved in, you I encourage both the board and the CEO is right after you figure out where you how your desk is gonna go in your office, you should figure out your succession plan. Not that it's gonna be done, but you're gonna normalize that conversation. Who have we got and like my um friend and colleague Peter Capelli talks about, we're long past designated individuals. You gotta work on developing pools of talent for subsequent consideration because who knows who's gonna be there or what you might need. And so um so that only complicates things when you haven't normalized that conversation. Now to you know, what kind of press release do you do? Well, I got a I I got multiple problems now. Um, because I if it if it's not him, who, right? Um, whereas if they'd been doing their job in a traditional sense, understanding this guy's a rock star in the world that he's in, um, this would have been something that would have been uh well in play because you've got you've got you've got people um around to to that you can turn to where uh you're already considering what's the fallback, etc. So I think one way you stay ahead of it is by actually doing the thing you're supposed to be doing, which is developing a succession plan and reviewing it regularly. So uh I mean what what would have happened if it if the guy had been in a plane crash? You would have had the same problem in the sense of I've got to replace him, and it wouldn't appear that that the organization would be any better equipped to do that than it is to handle the problem at hand. So the the notion of staying ahead of it, I mean, there's the communication piece of it, but I think it's also uh what's the what's the work that you're doing to stay ahead of it? Um and certainly when you discover things like appears to be true, that apart from what whoever this person was um who was involved in the um, you know, potentially involved the Chinese government, and were
Tom Muellerthey
Prof Gregory Sheawere they basically gray marketing chips through her to to the Chinese government. I mean, you know, I all that stuff uh will be complicated to sort up. However, to to uh to lie to the board, which apparently he did, at least about the second affair, right? Which would suggest it wasn't the best time to tell a lie. You're not if ever there's a good time to tell a lie, don't lie when you've been caught with both hands in a cookie jar. That's not the time to tell lies about the cookie jar. Um and then the the second uh piece about about that is the is the um is the violation of of the protocols that supposedly he's been an active verbal supporter of,
Tom Muelleruh,
Prof Gregory Sheawhich have to do with um you know the the nature of uh relationships inside personal relationships inside inside the organization, let alone across power lines, which are its own separate story.
Tom MuellerSo
Lying To The Board And Policy Breach
Prof Gregory Sheaum uh when you get to that point, uh you're you're way past at that point as a board, anything that has to do with how I'm gonna present this to the outside world. Now we're at key points regarding values in the organization. And what is my responsibility as a board member when I discover A, you did something that you're positively not supposed to do, and you said people shouldn't do it, and B, you lied to me about it. Okay, and my choice here would be what again?
Tom MuellerWell, the I can't help but think the second affair was a uh you know a lie by omission, probably, right? Keeping his his head down and then boom, surprise, New York Times digs it up, which makes you wonder what else is out there.
Prof Gregory SheaRight, exactly. And that's that's one of the things for the board is how do I how do I uh how to say in front of this? And at least by implication, it would appear, again, we only know what we we we can read in the press, but it would appear that given the opportunity at the very least, if not the question about are there other shoes about to drop here, um that uh there was there was nothing forthcoming. So uh and but now we're back to what's the nature of the relationship between
Tom Muellerthe
Prof Gregory Sheaboard chair and the the CEO. And if if I gotta ask you, if I have to do depositions with you, if I have to grill you, no, no, we're we we're done here. Like we're done here.
Tom MuellerRight. We've got to have that trusting relationship. And and uh you know, I can't help but dive into the psychology a little bit of where Jensen's head was through all of this. But you know, he's been hanging out, he's been a high flyer at conferences at the White House, you know, largest capped company in the world, you know, like you said, rock star, rocking the leather jacket wherever he goes, looking sharp. Um but yeah, sometimes it uh it gets away from us when we're in that uh in that position. Again, tale as old as time. This one, though, is fascinating because you know, you've got the potential Chinese spy angle that comes into it with the woman who is CEO of a vendor company that works with NVIDIA. And then the second alleged affair was with a vice president uh in the company there on staff. So uh he's crossing a lot of lines with uh with his personal behavior. And part of me wants to say, hey, you know what? He's a rock star. Let's find a way to make amends and keep him on and get him focused. But but if you're employees in that firm, you know, the example that you're seeing there, what's the discipline process? And is it fairly administered for lower level employees that it is for the execs? It really doesn't leave the board much room to to play with it.
Prof Gregory SheaNot if they believe in any of that stuff. You know, and if and if you again, from what we can read, if if they cave on this, um if I were consulting, I'd say you can cave, you should hand in your resignations. Because your ability to you do your job is gone now. And and I'm talking particularly just if we go about the stuff we know, which is whatever you didn't touch on forth in the second one, that's a clear violation of company protocols. You probably at least implicitly lie to the board, if not explicitly. General counsel had to go to your house to get you to Annie up on what I mean. Okay, so so so now you're instead of trying to find another CEO, you should find another board.
Tom MuellerOkay, well that's fascinating. That's a very dramatic take on this, then you're saying the board. What's
Prof Gregory Sheatheir job?
Tom MuellerIt it is, and they dropped the ball, right?
Prof Gregory SheaYou dropped the ball and then you you fumbled it, then you kicked it, and then and and and you didn't chase it after you kicked it. If that's if we play out this little metaphor, right? So and the ball's
Tom Muellerstill rolling, isn't it?
Prof Gregory SheaWhat what do you what are you gonna do about this, right? And
Public Anger Over Elite Double Standards
Tom Muellerso
Prof Gregory SheaI think that's uh and I think you know when you think more more broadly about the context, you know, kind of the zeitgeist that this is occurring in. Um we're at least a quarter of a century into um a growing sense of uh I think rage on the part of many parts of the world, certainly inside the the US um political domain, about so uh tell me how many, how many, how much difference there is between the elites and us in terms of how they get handled,
Tom Muellerright? Right.
Prof Gregory SheaUm so you're you're gonna you're gonna plug it if he comes back and gets oh yeah, he's fine, don't worry about it. We'll we'll fix it, the rest of it. It'll be really um, you know, and and as long as we're in here, can we talk about the financial crisis and what what happened with all the people who lost their houses because of aggressive sales, in part because of aggressive saling by you know, let's let's talk about um the amount of um you know outrage regarding the the the the the apparent dual standard in terms of the handling of elites um as reflected in the last you know themes in the last election. So if you really want to pour some gasoline on that fire, this is there is an opportunity here to do that.
Tom MuellerAll right. Well, I can't wait to see what happens this week uh watching that.
Investor Confidence Values And Long-Term Risk
Tom MuellerUm but you know, I was thinking about um you know potential board activities, but then shareholders, right? Stock price is down 25% essentially since this story broke. Uh so hugely in the red right now. And so clear indication that investors have lost confidence in the company, and yet their basic business plan, business model hasn't changed, right? It's a highly profitable company positioned on the cutting edge with a product that's going to be in high demand for years to come. But we've we've got this issue at the top of the house now. And you know, from an investor perspective, Greg, what do you see? You know, what do you think the mindset is out there? Because you can still make money on this stock.
Prof Gregory SheaWell, that's the whole issue, right? Or one of the issues is so what what are values worth to you?
Tom MuellerYeah.
Prof Gregory SheaI mean, you know, and and and both today and in five years from now, what are they worth to you, right? So if you've got an organization I mean um regardless of whether he stayed or didn't stay, he can't stay forever. Um and he's in his early 60s, right? So you're gonna have to face this problem of what do you do after him? And it's not just succession in terms of person, he supposedly has 60 direct reports. Well, that's not the way you set up an organization if if you're trying, if you're if you're trying to uh come up with any kind of structure that might yield something that could endure past an individual, right? So so you've got you've got multiple dimensions of the succession problem.
Tom MuellerAnd
Prof Gregory Sheawhen does that when does that that whole issue of how you set the thing up, what comes after him, when does that kick in, right? So uh we can say, well, yeah, there's a lot of money on the table, yeah, and you know, do you do you want your pain and agony now in this context, or do you want to wait a few years uh and do it in some other context? I I'm not trying to be flippant about that, I'm just saying it it's a problem, right, in terms of managing any kind of transition when you've got something like this. And ideally, the best CEOs and boards are preparing for that. They don't they don't just let that play out for another quarter, right, or another year.
Tom MuellerThey're
Prof Gregory Sheathey're on top, they're on top of that. And who, you know, who who is it that's keeping track of his mortality? I mean, I'm not sure he is, right? You know. Um, so somebody should be keeping track track of the fact that we have a human being here, and even if he lives to be 80, he's probably not gonna have the same competencies in five to ten years that he's got now, and how have you set that up? And it's having direct reports of 60, is that gonna make that work better? I mean, all that stuff uh I think plays into how one thinks about the transition. And if if it's only about, well, look what we're gonna lose in the short term, well, you you're probably, unless you're doing some of these things, you're gonna face that at some point um anyway. And I think that's part of the problem when we look uh again at the at the macro point. We you know, the concentration of power inside the stock market in AI, and the concentration of power inside the economy, um, these are all playing out as themes inside this as well, right? So, so how much sway do the handful of um tech bros have uh in terms of what happens next? And if one's thinking at on a policy level, how much do you want to give them? So there's a whole nother, I think, set of issues when you think about what's the quote right thing to happen here.
Tom MuellerWell, the elephant in the room, as you pointed out, is what are your values? What do you stand for? We have policies, are we enforcing those or not? And I can almost guarantee there's somebody in that company who's been disciplined because of a similar relationship, right? That uh we would probably hear about uh that if the if Jensen was treated differently than they've treated other staff in there. That'll be a whole nother New York Times expose story there.
Due Process Petitions And Decisive Discipline
Tom MuellerUm one of the humorous aspects to this, which uh is it's blowing me away here a little bit, is the online petition to save Jensen. And I checked on that this morning, and we're recording this on uh Monday morning.
Prof Gregory Shea180,000 or 170,000?
Tom Mueller180,000 signatories to that, including Elon Musk. Um interestingly, the petition you know doesn't lobby for Jensen personally, but it lobbies for due process, saying there needs to be due process follow the investigation, let it run its course, and then you can take action on it. And um of course they're looking in from the outside and don't don't know everything the board knows or the senior leadership knows there. But have you ever seen a petition like that for a CEO?
Prof Gregory SheaI I have, and I'm probably not the A number one um source on that, but I I think you know it's it's hard to argue against due process, um, except he did resign. He was not fired.
Tom MuellerRight.
Prof Gregory SheaSo if if he wanted to take it to the mat, he had he he didn't have to resign. Now, I'm not saying it would be easy not to resign, right? But but we I think we need to figure that into the into the equation. Um I um I a quick story. I worked with a um um uh one of my favorite COOs ever. Uh and he had been in an organization that was rife with kind of um uh a set of affairs that really to say complicated his life would be an understatement. Um it it just it just everything was um kind of twisted and upside down in terms of the the way the organization functioned because of this kind of crisscrossing affairs. Um and so when he took over um as COO of the organization when I worked with him, he um he was adamant that that was not gonna happen. Um and he got involved in a case of somebody you know three or four levels down from him who had been in. Involved in harassment and very inappropriate behavior. And and he took it on you know they're they're going through different processes and finally he said, I'm I'm intervening in this. Um and he he talked to the guy directly um and and he said look he said whatever else is true know that my eyes are now on you and if this doesn't cease you will be gone in a heartbeat because I have zero tolerance for this and you as a member of management which he was are responsible for that well the whole bunch of things happened but one of the key things that happened was he he he um after about I don't know four months or something broke broke ranks on what he had agreed to and the COO immediately became aware of it um because he was in the loop and he went he went to uh his HR person and said he's gone he's gone by five o'clock and the the HR person said well he got all kinds of protocols and panels he said he's gone by five o'clock now he said the reason we're gonna do it that way is first of all if he wants to sue me or us and wants to have this in open court
Tom Muelleras
Prof Gregory Sheaa married man with children I'm happy to meet him in open court we'll work this out right there he said and he said the other thing is which is very much I think in the spirit of your communications role in organizations he said I won't have to explain anything about why he's gone because the entire organization will know as soon as he's gone why he's gone and I don't have to issue any statement and he said that's what I want is I want that clarity of understanding about this and of course they went back and forth and people kidding about how much how much foot traffic there was back and forth between the HR the HR office and the COO's office but he was gone by two o'clock not five o'clock all right and and he didn't sue
Tom Muellerbecause
Prof Gregory Sheaexactly the CO expected he didn't want that in the public record he didn't want that enough problems
Tom Muellergreat example um of a you know board or leadership taking very clear action and you know what that's a morale booster for your employees who
Prof Gregory Sheaand it makes it real clear about you know what what it means to work here.
Tom MuellerRight. Well because of the environment today too you know you can get harassment claims for you know relatively I don't know what I might consider minor insults or perceived insults and stuff and but it's we just seem to be living in a hypersensitive time right now where those kind of things can turn into employee lawsuits if management doesn't take care and fix the problems.
Prof Gregory SheaWell and I think I think Tom in this particular case also it wasn't like it was just a bolt out of the blue he got purposely involved in something that had had several incidents with his character before and so he's intervening in a context so was there full due process after no was this a surprise that these are the rules and there were no right so um so to your yeah we can be overly sensitive but if somebody's a repeat offender and you show up um that's that's different than what somebody might perceive as a nuance on something else around the no that that's yeah there when you're sleeping with a direct report when that's not the when you're supposed to not do and you've given public a clin um support to the fact that that shouldn't happen okay now we got to figure out whether that actually happened or not but he resigned.
Tom MuellerYeah he did and that's you know an admission kind of right up front the petition you know seems to skirt that a little bit uh but you're right he did resign which means he is aware of the issues and the fact that there may be other issues that we haven't heard about yet uh and so trying to just pull the plug on that but this one gets interesting again because you have Congress talking about holding hearings over this now.
Congress Investigations And Comms Road Ahead
Tom MuellerNow is that actual you know government security issues they want to raise or is it just an opportunity to harass the administration over lex oversight all of those factors come into play but the fact is Nvidia's the baseball in this match now and they're gonna get batted around a lot. So the broader organization is going to be dealing with the fallout of this for you know months probably as we see you know congressional hearings or other FBI investigations happening and all that. So from a communication side a lot of work coming because you've still got to maintain your uh business as usual and reassure customer shareholders all that while congressional leaders are dragging your company through the mud and uh you know looking for political leverage or even just answers if you want to take it at face value. But it's gonna be a long road ahead for the company. Kind of a hard time to recruit a new CEO isn't it?
Prof Gregory SheaYeah I would think uh and I you know not that they're gonna ask me but if someone did I'd say you you you want to get somebody who's really going to get you back to your core business. It's gonna focus on that is going to think about what's going to come next is busy um creating an organizational structure that can last over time without stolifying the um the innovation there um and it's gonna really focus on that work. The other stuff should be stuff that gets managed out there. But you you gotta the more that an organization is in crisis of any kind of crisis the more it's it should get right back to basics right really right back into the work so people can get centered uh uh about that right have a I have a uh a short funny Vince Lombardi story about this um so from my generation Vince Lombardi is you know one of the gods of football coaching and stuff and notable notable for his intensity his passion um and he he used to keep this is under the heading of staffing he kept a guy around named Max McGee for several years past the time that Max probably should have been playing in an NFL um and as far as I can tell he kept him around because McGee was somebody even though he's a player who didn't have trouble keeping Lombardi in line when when he went too far right so there's a story about um the Packers had played one of their unusually bad games they didn't I mean they didn't play a lot of bad games um but Lombardi was absolutely incensed at how badly they played and so he starts off the the the Monday meeting of the team saying um you know given that performance we have to go back to basics and so he holds up a football and he says this gentleman is a football at which point at which point McGee raises his hand and and and lombardi too supposedly through like clenched he says yes McGee and Max McGee says could you slow it down a little coach and supposedly there's a moment where people didn't know if McGee was going to lose his head literally in a moment
Tom Muellerbut then
Prof Gregory SheaLombardi started laughing you know and and said all right okay so but the point of after any major defeat is that you want to get back to basics but not be insulting about how to go about doing it.
Tom MuellerAnd
Prof Gregory Sheapart of the staffing issue is yeah you want somebody who's really good running the thing but you also want them to be open to the kind of Max McGee input that's going to help them keep some balance through this thing.
Tom MuellerYeah. Yeah it's gonna be you know a fascinating opportunity for somebody to step in there and I'm just thinking about you know engaging with employees reassuring everybody trying to as you said re-center people so that they can keep rolling and you know keep this massive money machine rolling along and that so yep all good um any other any other closing thoughts on this Greg as we roll out
Power Corrupts And The Need For Truth-Tellers
Prof Gregory Sheait'd be nice to have a closing thought Tom
Tom Muellerright
Prof Gregory Sheathat we could say this is we've closed this down. And this is my I think the big thing is and as you said sev said several times this is old as time that um the the danger of power um whether it's absolute power corrupts absolutely absolute power, but you get filled up with a false sense of no the rules don't apply to me and all of that right which is one of the reasons that back to the Lombardi sort you want Max McGee's around you want people around who will be honest with you you you you you you purposely get those people in you know um and and you don't spin them out just because they disagree with you or have got something that no you you trust them you trust their judgment you trust their their morality you trust their honesty that you need those people around you um and you you need at least a couple who are really close to you and hopefully one of those is your your board chair but in anybody um whether you're a lieutenant and your relationship with your master sergeant or whether you're a CEO um and your relationship or your board chair and relationship with a CEO you need those kinds of people and you need to hire the kinds of people who will who will volunteer truth to you about stuff.
Closing Thanks And How To Reach Us
Tom MuellerAll right there you have it management from the experts management advice from the expert Dr. Greg Shea Greg thanks for for joining us again uh on the podcast today for this quick hot take on NVIDIA uh lots to watch as we go forward here so really appreciate you volunteering your perspective on this and uh we'll see how it plays out now right
Prof Gregory Sheastay tuned
Tom Muellerand that's going to do it for this episode of the Leading in a Crisis podcast thanks for joining us if you want to drop me a line you can email me at tom at leadinginacrisis dot com and we will see you again soon for another episode. Take care