The Leading in a Crisis Podcast
What really happens when a crisis hits an organization—and how technology is influencing decisions and reputation impacts. Come hear what happened when experienced leaders were actually in the middle of a crisis—and capture the lessons before it happens to you. Email the show at Tom@leadinginacrisis.com.
Your host, Tom Mueller, is a veteran crisis manager and trainer with more than 30 years in the corporate communications and crisis fields. Tom currently works as an executive coach and crisis trainer with WPNT Communications, and as a contract public information officer and trainer through his personal company, Tom Mueller Communications LLC.
Our goal is to help you grow your knowledge and awareness so you can be better prepared to lead should a major crisis threaten your organization.
Music credit: Special thanks to Nick Longoria from Austin, Texas for creating the theme music for the podcast.
#crisis #crisismanagement #crisiscomms #crisiscommunications
#BusinessContinuity #LeadingThroughCrisis
#CrisisResponse #management #leadership
The Leading in a Crisis Podcast
When skyscrapers fall 2 - FDNY transforms itself after the 911 trauma
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We continue our conversation with the authors of Rising From Ground Zero about what FDNY learned after 9/11 and why real recovery depends on trust, not just tactics. We focus on the human side of crisis leadership: how leaders show up, how grief changes people, and how an organization can open itself to outside help without losing its identity.
• the power imbalance between helper and helped and why listening matters
• why the best idea is the one people will accept and use
• FDNY choosing permeable boundaries by bringing in outside training and partners
• incident management teams evolving from local capacity to national deployments
• building counseling and peer support that fits firehouse culture
• shifting norms from stigma to treatment as a sign of strength
• leadership presence as real work including station visits and funerals
• resilience as a long arc of grieving rather than quick closure
• meaning and agency as foundations for recovery and performance
by buying this book and diving into it
Our guests were Paul Brown, Prof. Gregory Shea, and Andre Kotze.
Find more details about these authors and the book at https://www.risingfromgroundzero.org.
#risingfromgroundzero #resilience #911response #ptsd #recovery #crisiscomms #emergencymanagement #FDNY
We'd love to hear from you. Email the show at Tom@leadinginacrisis.com.
Hi
Welcome And Book Context
Tom Muellereveryone and welcome back to Leading in a Crisis Podcast Feel. Our program today we're continuing our conversation with veterans from the 9-11 attack and the lessons learned by the Fire Department of New York during that incident response and in the subsequent weeks and months after that. It's a fascinating conversation, uh, which features in their new book, which is called Rising from Ground Zero, 9-11 and the FDNY's Path Through Crisis to Transformation. That's a mouthful. But it's a fascinating read, and the conversation uh that we conclude here with the gentleman today is equally fascinating. I hope you'll enjoy it.
Andre KotzeUm
The Power Dynamic Of Helping
Andre Kotzehelping is such a tricky um field. Um if you are being helped, uh you you are in a very vulnerable place, and you've you've got to admit you're in a vulnerable place. So to be open to help, to ask for help, I mean that that's that's one set of problems uh that uh we're dealing with in an environment like this. Um the other set of problems is how do the helpers show up? And I think Greg's story was trying to uh explore this. And I'm I'm I'm going into this detail because hopefully somebody is listening that is going to be either needing help in the future or in a position to help. And um uh so the helper has everything that the the person being helped or the organization being helped needs, it's a very powerful place, albeit temporal. And um, so you might think of the helper having power over the helped. And and now we're into all kinds of uh ego uh issues here.
Tom MuellerUm it's not easy to accept help for a lot of us, right?
Andre KotzeNo, especially not when we are the last line of defense. Like we we are the guys, we don't get helped, we help. Um, and I don't say that being a fighter uh uh FDNY member, I am not, uh, but I have been a mountain rescuer, I've been a soldier. Um uh I understand what it means to have that kind of a spread of call, a spread of call. So um for for those who might find themselves in a helping position in uh in the future, the the piece uh to underline about what that was in the story Greg was telling um is just to actively manage that dynamic. And it's why listening uh was so important. It's why uh putting yourself in service of, even though you have all this power and capability that you can bring to bear, um, if you can't somehow uh create this uh agreement with the person needing help, uh, that you are the person to bring them that help. It doesn't matter what you've got in your back pocket, it's not gonna make a difference. Um, your your ability to work with the person, to work with the patient, to work with the organization that needs help is very much uh part of what needs to be in the helper's repertoire. Um uh so I would just uh offer that perspective um around helping. And to say that FDNY knew what they needed uh um uh in the form of that task force. Uh but to our earlier points, those things weren't already in place at the time of the crisis. And if it's not there when you need it, you're not going to develop it in the flow. Um, it's all got to be built in advance, um, which is uh perhaps where we get into the next uh chapter of the story around the transformation of FDNY um and its um uh engagement with the uh incident incident management teams.
Prof. Gregory SheaSo Professor. Tom, that's why we dedicated the entire chapter just to this story. Um, is that it's uh to Andre's point, is so important. Um and it comes into play in so many people for so many people and so many different times uh in organizations and and for individuals. Uh and it's it's one that's both the story, and then we've made reference a couple of times here to Ed Schein's work. Um so there are principles laid out, we're trying to make it very grounded, as you know from having read the book, and it's a great example of the best idea is not the best idea. The best idea is the best idea you can get implemented, and they figured that out. So I'm sorry, I talked over your time.
Tom MuellerNo, I
Opening Up To Outside Expertise
Tom Muellerwas just gonna ask if you uh wanted to add anything to that on the broader lessons learned. Um yeah. If so, is the broader message then for you know other organizations, agencies that you just you you you may not know what you don't know. You need to be open to uh taking that assistance. Um it's just it's it's funny. I think back on a colleague I had at BP who uh was not a big fan of the um emergency management system and all of that, kind of tend to favored we'll deal with the press and that'll take care of most of the problems that we have. You guys can fiddle around down there with, you know, oil spills and whatever, but we'll take care of it until he got put into a role of, you know, fiddling with oil spills and all of that. And uh, it was just such an eye-opening experience for him and um to understand the level of training and uh people and technology that goes into being prepared to deal with a major incident like that. So are there any broader lessons for you know executives out there that come out of that?
Prof. Gregory SheaI I I'll start us just by saying that I think uh again, kind of the the broader meta lesson here is the FTNY, and Paul had lots to say about this, um uh really opened itself up to outsiders. And this is one of the key parts of that initial opening. And once you've done that, once you start opening yourself up to outside training, which Paul can talk about how that happened in all kinds of ways and continues to happen, um, you start opening yourself up to exposure, you start making yourself so good as that resource on incident management yourself that you get called in by the forestry folks to help them when they need help, right? So you move from student to partner in this stuff. I mean, once you're doing that, you're really opening up, in my world, you call you you move from impermeable to permeable boundaries around the organization. Um, you are now in an entirely different world than you are when you say, we're we're the FBY, and rightly so, we can claim we're the best or the second best or whatever it is on the planet, and that's all we need to know. We open ourselves up. And this is a big part of that. So I think the broadest lesson from this is once you start this process of opening yourself up, you may find that there's actually a whole bunch of stuff for you to go and learn and and process and then deal with the consequences of having learned it, teaching it, learning more, et cetera, right?
Tom MuellerYou're gonna get busier and busier. That was one of the the uh fascinating points in here, too, is how the the FDNY teams became resources then to support other organizations and being deployed in other states to help deal with major incidents. That's just a testament to the growth and the transformation that occurred within the department, you know, over those years.
Prof. Gregory SheaAnd Tom, while they were doing that, they were doing the same thing on the side of counseling services, et cetera. So they've become a go-to resource for that aspect. So it's not, it's not, quote, just the technical part or the managerial part, it's also the caring for their member part, which um both Andre and um Paul may very well have something to say about.
Tom MuellerYeah,
Peer Counseling That Actually Works
Tom Muellerlet's just spend a quick minute on that. Uh, where uh you know, the formation of the ceremonial unit within the department to uh to help honor you know these milestones and different things. Is that kind of where you were getting to with that?
Prof. Gregory SheaWell, I think there's a whole set of both providing the resources, but then making the adjustments necessary to people use the resources to go from an organization that before 9-11, as one of the interviewees said, we took our therapy out of a bottle to an organization that's a paramilitary organization and you don't need instruction about what that means in terms of norms about toughness and embrace the suck and all the stuff that that means, right? To a place where if you're not getting uh treatment for a psychological or an emotional consequence, uh particularly of the work you do, what is your problem? That is a huge change inside that organ inside that organization. And they actively went after changing those norms. And Paul's got more than a little and personal stuff uh in particular, including his father, about just that transition.
Tom MuellerYeah, Paul, you want to share a story there?
Paul BrownYeah, I will. I'll quickly just touch on the ceremonial previously uh you know the FDNY historically is not unacquainted with death within its ranks. So, excluding the World Trade Center, there were 49 line of duty deaths during my career. 49 firefighters were killed on the job during my career. Well, what we would do is there was a ceremonial unit, but they were people who had day jobs. They were in firehouses, they were in headquarters, they were in support units, and if we had uh a fatality, they would be pulled out of those roles, those roles for a number of days, and they would handle the ceremonial part, and then they would go back to their job. After the World Trade Center, we stood up a full-time unit to take care of that function, but they still supplement with people from the outside. Then what ended up happening is after we went through all of the World Trade Center uh you know funerals and memorials, people started dying of the illnesses. Uh, I believe we're up to about 470 post-event deaths due to illnesses. So there there is a has been a consistent need for that ceremonial function. What else the department did is the counseling was mainly historic historically it it was was for substance abuse. And there was such a need after the World Trade Center. So one of the the statistics is that 98% of FDNY firefighters knew someone who was killed, and 78% had a close relationship with someone who was killed. There was a large need. They brought people in, but there was a little bit of a mismatch. Uh you know, there's a story of they had one counselor who was sent to a firehouse and he came in wearing a suit and he sat in the corner of the kitchen reading the New York Times up in front of him and said, What nobody's coming to talk to me. Yeah, I wonder why. So the department, being very results-based, didn't just say, Hey, you know, we tried, the services are available, we can't make them come. They found a way to bridge that gap. And what they did is they brought in older retired firefighters who had some background or experience with counseling. The ones who were certified counselors, like my dad, were brought in and became a counselor. He was in the counseling service unit for over 10 years. He canceled over a thousand firefighters, and he was somebody who spent a long time on a job. He'd he'd been there, he'd done that. He didn't, they didn't have to spend any time explaining the job or explaining what happens at these incidents, or what it feels like to lose someone you work with, because he'd experienced that, and they were able to just get right down to it. The other thing they did to bridge the gap is they brought in other folks not to act as sit-down, have a session counselors, but to be almost like traffic cops or air traffic controllers. Show up in the firehouse, it's an older firefighter. So I had an incident um unsuccessful CPR on a two-year-old, and we're driving back to the firehouse, and the back of the rig was silent. Anyone who's been on a fire truck, it's never quiet in the back of the rig. I realized everyone working was a parent, so I called up the counseling unit, they sent the peers over, they purposely called firefighters who had worked in the area. One of them had worked with my dad. I recognized him as soon as he came in. Gathered the guys, I introduced him. I know him, he worked with my dad. This is another guy. He worked two firehouses over, he worked in this neighborhood. Um, and what they do is they just explain about how what services are available, what you might be experiencing feeling, what may come up, what might happen so that you're not surprised when these things happen internally. And here's the numbers to call. And you don't have to make an appointment. But if you want to, someone on the other end of that phone will listen. And that's how the department bridged the gap and continues to do that to this day.
Tom MuellerWell, that's a huge success story, um, Paul. And you've got me thinking um uh back to my experiences on the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, right? And after six months of people being deployed, they got sent back to the office to sit in their cubicles and you know, would sit there and kind of stare at the walls, right? They've been going and going and dealing with so many things for so long, and now they're sitting back in their old jobs. And the PTSD was a real factor there. So, um, what's the broader lesson out of that, guys, for organizations that go through major situations like this? I mean, we always heard, hey, here's the phone number for the employee assistance program. You know, if you need help, you can call them. Uh, but boy, it just never felt like a real option for me. So, Andre, you got some thoughts on that?
Leadership Starts With Tending People
Andre KotzeUh yes, uh, I I believe all three of us will. Um, there was a moment on uh 9-11 when those who were there attribute the re-establishment of command and control. And um it's well documented in the book. There's an image there of Pete Hayden uh standing on top of a firetruck, and happened around around noon. Um and uh uh he essentially uh called people to present. And uh he did that with a moment of silence. And after that moment of silence, he uh asked folk to come to the front of the where the firetruck was, uh and uh the officers were uh to receive their uh their orders and to go back about their business. So leadership was present throughout, but when command and control first made itself felt, the very first thing that it did is it tended the people. And I think that is a uh a universal lesson. Um we can we can get lost in the work, um and uh just the importance uh from the highest level of tending to the person and starting from that corner out. The fire's still burning start in that corner.
Tom MuellerIt's a huge statement to the organization.
Prof. Gregory SheaSo Dan Nigro, who was the senior person, left after this, visited every firehouse. Every firehouse in New York City. And he didn't go there to make a speech. He went there to be with people and to listen to people. And as he said to us, he graciously gave us two two-hour interviews, including when he was sick. Um and he said um that some of that was hard work because you know you have people there, what are you gonna do next time? What happened? How could all that stuff? But he was not there to have a PR moment. He was there to be with those people. And all you gotta do is look at Dan, and you can tell he was with those people. Um he absorbed that, right? Um and and I think that one of the one of the lessons out of this, Tom, is that particularly in some of the more casual, popular literature currently, right, is that uh resilience, you know, you take the Rocky Bellboa shot to the chin, you get to the mat, you get up, and you know, you get on with it. It's kind of the popular version of just get through it, you'll be okay, you'll get closure in the event, you'll get on with your life. Well, if it's a big deal, um it's not about the day, it's about the months and years afterward. That's what it's about. And it's about the grieving that you will now have as part of your life. You will be grieving. You'll grieve less in the future than today, but you're gonna have to work through this. And that's something that is a process, right? And you've got to incorporate the grieving itself as well as this chapter into your life. It doesn't have to be your life, that's part of the work, but it's gonna be a a big, it's gonna be a part of your life now, it's part of the book of your life, and you're gonna honor that. And so healing, grieving, don't look for closure, don't look for some type of, oh, I bounced up, I'm okay. No, this is not one of those, right? And I think that's part in the spirit of what Andre's talking about, that's part of recognizing when it's not just a matter of getting through the day, get a good night's sleep, and we'll see you tomorrow. No, this has far more consequence to you as a human being. And if you want to connect with these people and you want to lead them, you better be part of their connection and their grieving and their healing, both formally and informally at the funerals, and you go and talk to them in those firehouses.
Tom MuellerWow, the emotional gosh, energy you would need to do that, right? To visit every firehouse, to go to those funerals. Um, it's it's just, I mean, it's it's impressive, it's mind-boggling, and and they they did that.
Prof. Gregory SheaAnd I'd say the very fact, just so you identified, Tom, it's it's hard work, it's real work, and that's why so many leaders don't do it. And and the organization and the people in those organizations pay a price for them not doing it.
Tom MuellerYeah, I think that's true, and you can see that in organizations that don't feel well connected together, that a spree decor isn't there, and all of that. Well,
Incident Management And Training Transformation
Tom Muellerlisten, fascinating conversation, but I do want to touch on the the broader transformation issues that uh FDNY went through and that journey a little bit, because it was fascinating to sort of read through how all that progressed. And I know you guys have written extensively about that in the book. Uh I wonder, Paul, can I can I start with you and just thinking about you know what were the the layers of transformation? Because we're we're talking about guys digging through rubble at the tower.
Paul Brownbases to suddenly you know years later guys who are deploying you know externally to go help other people what happened in the interim there you know a few things that happened that sort of snowball is after the World Trade Center the the FDNY then created its own incident management team and the first deployment was to New Orleans following uh or I should say first deployment outside of New York City was to uh down to New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and the thing that you heard from most people in in the kitchen where a conversation's happening is that so many people came to New York and they helped us and now we have an ability to go and help other people now when you zoom out a little bit and you look at the bigger picture the size of FDNY as an organization allows it to have these stand up entities standalone entities not only did the FDNY send an incident management team to New Orleans to help we sent 500 firefighters to relieve the New Orleans firefighters of their day-to-day duties for two weeks it was a drop in the bucket of New York it had zero effect on New York City's ability to answer the calls and fight the fires in New York City and after that two weeks was over what did we do? Sent another 500 and relieved them for another two week period and it was this feeling of we can finally give back we have something positive that we can help you know the the larger national and world community who came to help us and then those of us who were in the Instant Management we would start going to these wildfires and interacting with all these different agencies in different parts of the country and and you know learning from these people learning about leadership and in even the classwork they did was was just fantastic. And then word would spread in the department I'm getting this great training I'm going to these great classes and it just snowballed within the department and the other part about the size of the FDNY is we can also host a class. We always have enough people to fill a classroom to bring in an instructor but we don't fill the classroom solely with FDNY we always leave seats for other agencies to get different voices in the room and to bring people in to develop relationships for the future and that is one of those things that snowballed happened more and more and it and it continues to this day.
Tom MuellerAnd it strikes me that training was was and the level of training the sophistication of the training was one of the critical factors in that transformation right they talk about the establishment of the uh center for terrorism and disaster preparedness within um the fire department and then the level of training that went with that there was uh coordination with the West Point Training Institute tell me a little bit about about that and you know how did that what did that look like in the organization that was part of that snowball effect where the this this the quality of training that we were receiving from outside entities also what had happened is especially in regards to uh strategic thinking and leadership prior to the World Trade Center that type of thinking and training for strategy and leadership did not reach to even a mid-level in the FDNY let alone the lower levels or firefighters or even company officers now today lieutenants receive leadership training they're taught about you know strategic thinking um you know I think Greg and Andre could actually have a little more than this uh Greg was involved in some of that training.
Prof. Gregory SheaSo I've I've I've done some teaching in the FDNY the the the core set of people as well as I've taught at the terrorism center right and so people from Columbia I'm from Wharton um people from the different academies have been have been involved and I think that when you ask about what are any closing lessons I think going back to something and this is evidence of this what Paul's talking about the FDNY could have chosen just to rebuild itself shut itself down dig a deeper moat and cut itself off from the world and it did exactly the opposite and as it started to open itself up it just opened itself it just kept opening itself up further. And that really is remarkable as somebody who spent most of his career studying organizational change we know for decades of study that most change fails. The majority of change fails 55 to 70% or so fail. The FDNY didn't have to do it that even makes it less likely it's going to succeed right but they chose to do it and they did it so well that we can talk about the multiple levels of changes that occurred and are still there today in the FDNY but the core thing has to do was they didn't close up and shut down they opened up and expanded how the how the world could come in and what they could take from the world and what they could give back to the world.
Andre KotzeThat's
Staying Open When Change Usually Fails
Andre KotzeTom Mueller
a pretty remarkable thing and you know for for broader organizations out there what are the the key leadership takeaways uh from that and generally from your experiences in the book that you want people to be aware of here when we get good at something uh we can begin to feel very comfortable inside of what we're good at a teacher of mine once described development like uh breaking through a glass bell jar you know we we run up against our limits we break through those limits all of a sudden we in all of this great new open space and uh all we encounter is another bell jar um the fundamental openness needs to remain open we can't begin to feel comfortable and confident in what we know now we experts in this new thing and i would i would just say to any executive that's looking to be adaptable in the face of of things like this know what you know um use what you know it's very effective stay curious stay open um uh maintain connectivity relationships networks um uh rely on the people around you uh outside of you in as much as you have to rely on yourself and those that report to you and work with you so this this issue of openness um it's it's not a one and done thing uh it's a continuously needing to open yourself up um to uh to to what is uh to to what is out there and what is emerging um and yeah perhaps uh that's all um uh from me at this moment Tom okay professor Shea other leadership lessons you want to just highlight overall from the from the book you got another hour indeed well um because uh we we wrote the book to capture the stories first first and foremost and secondly to to try to um help to pass them on and to explicate mind them pass them on um I would say on on the biggest level across the whole arc of the story the the FDNY the firefighter in the F DNY knows why they do what they do they've made a choice about having this as what they do and having meaning in what you do whatever it is right what that's a matter not just of somebody giving you a mission that's a matter you have to make an assent that that's why I'm doing this.
Meaning And Agency After Trauma
Prof. Gregory SheaSo they they are firefighters and that means something to them. And carrying meaning with you will help you uh whenever you get smacked upside the head by a two by with a two by four it will help in terms of of then deciding well in this this means that I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna keep being a firefighter I'm gonna rise from my knees and I'm gonna put out the car fighter next to me next to me although I don't know what the grand plan is here who knows if there is one I'm gonna take because I'm a firefighter. That's very important if one is thought back to where we started how you prepare for not just the day but the long piece of this what does it mean to be a firefighter and you've made an ascent to that and the organization supports that. And then the second thing is that leads to a sense of agency. There are things I can do there are things I can do right where I am and if I don't have a meaning and I don't have a sense of agency it's really hard not just to get through the 11th of September it's really hard to get through the months and the years that follow that in terms of trying to incorporate all of that into how you think about what you're doing, why you're doing it, whether you should do anything, what can I do? So I'd go back to those two big things is a sense of meaning that the person has and then with that is that to support that sense of agency. So as Paul says when they pull up to a fire that we got stuff we got to do here right I'm out there doing that stuff. That's so key to someone in the moment of the crisis to use Andre's words as well as when you think about trying to process the crisis what am I going to do about this? How am I going to incorporate this?
Giving Back And Closing Reflections
Tom MuellerOkay Paul, I'd love to hear your closing thoughts and and feelings around this whole project that you've undertaken here doing this book and working with these fine gentlemen.
Paul BrownClose it out for us I think the biggest piece is what what a what an honor it was for all of these folks to you know share their experience with us um and to uh trust us to treat it in the most respectful manner. You know I'd also like to mention um that part of our getting together to write the book uh our agreement is includes that uh 51% of any uh profits from the book will go to FDNY related charities um the book with the cooperation of our publisher uh is as a very low price point because it's about getting the information out there getting the lived experience of the firefighters out there as far as takeaway lessons you know it uh as I said at the beginning uh FDNY prepared for 136 years and how things happen on the ground is that you have to empower people to act absent leadership because if they're only allowed to act under supervision when something like this happens and there's no supervision nothing will happen.
Tom MuellerWell there's many many great lessons in this book again the book is Rising from ground zero 9-11 and the FDNY's path through crisis to transformation well we've offered you just a snippet of what you can find out by buying this book and diving into it and I want to thank uh Paul Greg and Andre for taking the time to share that with us gentlemen we appreciate you thank you very much for being on thank you and that's gonna do it for this episode of Leaving in a crisis thanks for joining us if you want to reach it on leaving in a crisis And we'll see you again soon for another episode. Take care.